With replicas its always possible to point out a unique feature /modification your car had, that other replicas do not
If you filed a police report back then its still valid
If you filed an insurance claim you may have to give the car to the insurer or they may let you buy it for a few hundred bucks
If you never filed insurance claim or police report and just chalked it up as a loss you are probably still get cash or the car if the paper trail on it shows a bond was posted to get a new title
Its well worth investigating . Heck i can help you and will buy it back if your insurer sells it