I know you are a stickler for accuracy but take a look at this:
1993-1996 VW Eurovan GLS/Golf (Lens P/N 1H6-945-131 [replaced by P/N 7D0-945-131], Housing P/N 701-945-213).
I've used this on my build and it is very nice looking on the NAERC body as well as almost identical to OEM.